Editorial and Peer Review Policy

The editorial policy of the EDUKASI is mainly based on the “Code of Conduct and Best-Practice Guidelines for Journal Editors” published by the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE).

EDUKASI adheres also to the “Principles of Transparency and Best Practice in Scholarly Publishing” jointly published by COPE, the Directory of Open Access Journals, the Open Access Scholarly Publishers Association and the World Association of Medical Editors.

EDUKASI publishes only original scholarly works. All manuscripts submitted to EDUKASI are rigorously evaluated via a double-blind peer-review process. The manuscripts should be original, unpublished, and not in consideration for publication elsewhere at the time of submission.

Submission

If you are interested in submitting a manuscript to EDUKASI, please refer to Author Guidelines for information on how to prepare and submit your manuscript.  

Preliminary evaluation
All submitted manuscripts are read and evaluated firstly by the editorial staff. The papers which are not fit the journal’s scope or are judged to be of insufficient general interest are rejected without external review. For detailed information on the journal’s scope, please refer to About the Journal.

Peer review process
Manuscripts that passed the preliminary evaluation are sent to at least two external reviewers selected according to their specialities and academic skills. The peer-review process is carried out entirely through the online submission system. Reviewers are expected:
– to evaluate the scientific quality of the manuscript, especially its originality, validity, significance, ethical aspects, presentation quality and interest to the readers;
– to provide an overall recommendation for publication;
– to provide a review report.

Double-blind peer review
All submitted manuscripts are evaluated through a double-blind peer-review process. Double-blind peer review means that the reviewers don’t get to know the identity of the authors, and the authors don’t get to know the identity of the reviewers.

Ethical guidelines
EDUKASI: Jurnal Pendidikan Islam (e-Journal) follows strict ethical standards for publication to ensure high-quality scientific publications and public trust in research findings. Reviewers play a central role in ensuring the integrity and quality of the scholarly publication. They must conduct reviews in an ethical and accountable manner. Ethical guidelines for authors and reviewers who contribute to EDUKASI are detailed in our Publication Ethics and Plagiarism Policy.

Final decision
The Editor-in-Chief or the Guest Editor of a Special Issue make the final decision based on the reviewers’ recommendations, from among several possibilities:
– Accept in present form;
– Accept after minor revisions;
– Reconsider after major revisions;
– Reject.
If the revisions are required, authors will be asked to resubmit the revised manuscript within a certain period of time. In major revisions, the revised version of the manuscript will be returned to the reviewers and will be re-evaluated.

Appeals and Complaints Policy

Appeals

Authors have the right to appeal a decision on their submissions to the journals published by EDUKASI if they believe the decision was unfair. To appeal a decision, please submit a letter detailing the nature of the appeal and indicating why the decision is viewed as unfair.

The Editor-in-Chief will review all relevant documentation relating to the submission, may consult the relevant Associate Editor or Reviewers and may appoint a new Reviewer to evaluate the submission before making a decision. The decision of the Editor-in-Chief will be final.

Complaints

For complaints relating to the policies and procedures of EDUKASI or the conduct of editorial staff, please email the details of the complaint to the Editor-in-Chief or to the publisher, Tarbiyah Departement, STAI Muhammadiyah Tulungagung. All complaints directed through the correct channels will be acknowledged and the resolution will be conveyed to the complainant. Complaints will be resolved as quickly as possible.